Haunted Charleston History: Old Exchange and Provost Dungeon

Old Exchange and Provost Building Charleston

Old Exchange and Provost Building Charleston | Photo by: @young_preservationist

Table of Contents

Given that Charleston was founded in 1670, it isn’t surprising that there are several well-known ghost stories within the last 300+ years.

Since Halloween is officially less than a week away, we’ve decided to take a deep dive into one familiar landmark that is prevalent in the city’s haunted history: the Old Exchange and Provost Dungeon. 🕷

Located at 122 E. Bay St., this landmark dates back to 1771 and was originally constructed to serve as a commercial exchange + customs house. During the building’s 250 years in existence, it has also operated as a museum, city hall, military headquarters, and post office. The building’s underground dungeon, however, held pirates, enslaved people + war criminals. Upon entering the dungeon today, building visitors claim to be met with screams, dancing orbs, and other figures. 👻

Provost Dungeon in Charleston

Provost Dungeon | Photo by: @ellekhaye_

One individual in particular, Colonel Isaac Hayne, was among the countless individuals kept locked away in the provost dungeon before his execution. Hayne was charged with treason + was hanged in August of 1781.

Shortly before his public execution, Hayne was kept in what is now known as the Colonel Isaac Hayne room in the upstairs level of the Old Exchange and Provost Dungeon building — where some still believe his spirit remains.

Legend claims that en route to his execution, Hayne passed his sister’s house, who cried out + begged him to return to her — which he said he would do, if possible. Some claim to still hear the sound of his boots pacing down that street at night, returning to visit his sister as she had requested.

This is just one of many spooky stories that are part of the Lowcountry’s history. If you’re looking to embark on your own adventure learning more about each ghost story + haunted landmark in Charleston, we’ve got a roadmap that will give you pumpkin to talk about. 🎃

Poll

More from CHStoday
Join the annual event, Charleston by Design, to explore history through the lens of art and design.
CHStoday had the chance to chat with Oscar from One Beautiful Question about what inspires him and his work.
From award-wining country artists to chart-topping bands, there’s no shortage of concerts to enjoy live music in the Holy City this year — use this guide to find your next concert.
Spicewalla, an Asheville-based spice brand, is helping you add the flavors you love (from Chef Shuai Wang’s North Charleston restaurants) to your pantry.
The new rooftop restaurant will overlook the Cooper River and offer coastal Italian dishes.
The waterfront home in Riverland Terrace was owned by the Halsey family of WB Halsey Lumber Company.
The land and building set to house a new Mount Pleasant restaurant and event space, Frank & Jack’s, have been listed.
This downtown bookshop, Philosophers & Fools, is inviting the Charleston community to celebrate two years of drinks, snacks, and books.
Carolopolis Awards honor both private and public projects that preserve that history.
V Modern Italian aims to “feed your senses,” from the bites to the DJ-curated soundtrack, every detail comes together for a fully immersive experience.